Panther Warning: Avoid Font Book at All Costs

In my real life, I play someone who needs to be able to activate fonts on the fly, i.e. someone in a design capacity. I prefer to use an application to activate fonts, regardless of which computing platform I’m using.

For years, I’ve used Suitcase, Font Juggler and the best of the lot, Adobe Type Manager Deluxe (ATM). I still wax nostalgic for the way that ATM Deluxe auto-activated fonts. If I had neglected to activate a font, I didn’t really have to worry, as ATM would catch it. It made font management easy. It took the voodoo out of font management.

Along came Apple’s OS X. Apple, the former king of ease of use, decided to repeatedly kick both itself and it’s users squarely in the crotch (repeatedly) by having not one place for fonts to reside, but about 70 (at last count). This made font management software critical for designers. No longer could we slack on a freelance system and just drag a few fonts or folders to the System Folder. We had to watch our shit.

When Suitcase became available for OS X, everybody started cheering and things looked just swell. It supported (sort of) auto-activation, but because Adobe hates everybody except Microsoft, they forced the use of auto-activation plug-ins for their applications. Plus, the Suitcase interface left room for improvement. Because OS X has about 700 fonts activated at start up, seeing what fonts you have activated was a little weird. I’m sure readers of Slashdot or Ars Technica are ready to shoot me, but I’m going somewhere. Just bear with me, people.

Apple, obviously sensing Adobe’s shift in love (we can only blame Final Cut Pro), decided that with it’s latest system update, 10.3 nee, Panther, that it was time to once again show people how it’s done with a tantalizing font manager called Font Book. It’s Free! It has a metallic interface!

The problem is that it’s clearly meant for no one to actually use.

I added a few hundred fonts to it. It was very fast. I started to move towards my Suitcase CD to fling it into the air like I just graduated from college. Then, my machine, a dual G5 (work is nice) slowed to a crawl. I stopped my move towards the Suitcase CD. Upon further notice, I now had something like 1,900 fonts open and trying to close them all took about 45 minutes. Font Book started to respond, but then would randomly jump. Font names wouldn’t correspond with the preview. I screamed and fled.

I tried to reset everything back to normal, but when I installed Suitcase, I found that Font Book had done something with my fonts. They were gone from their original folders. Fortunately, I had a back up of my fonts and was able to overwrite the shell of a font folder.

I’m forced to ask what millions of Windows users have asked everyday, what in the name of God is Apple smoking releasing such a pile of useless crap?

  • http://www.blurbomat.com Lisa

    Word.

  • http://www.thehighsign.net lizpenn

    hmm, and i thought it was only my geeky illustrator boyfriend who nearly took up terrorism when he switched to osx and started using fontreserve last june. after much pounding of furniture and creative strings of obscenities, he actually wrote a long and hilarious letter to diamondsoft which i will duly append:

    >Dear tech support person:
    >
    > Just recently purchased Font Reserve 3.1.1
    >after many happy years of using ATM, which sadly >>>isnàt supported in OSX. I emailed earlier today >regarding my mounting frustration at not being able to
    > get Font Reserve to do anything other than create handsome organizations of
    > fonts within its own browser that have absolutely nothing to do with how my
    > fonts are organized (ie. activated and deactivated) within other apps. In
    > other words, it does nothing but look good.

    >The Font Reserve Browser indicates the correct list of activated fonts as
    > specified by me, but when I use any app (eg. illustrator 10.0.3, flashmx,
    > wordx, fireworksmx, etc.) all 2000 of my fonts come up as active in the
    > respective app. character window, which is what I’d hoped Font Reserve was
    > going to eliminate. This was the sole reason for its purchase.
    >
    > Since the directions in the anemic quick start guide accompanying the
    > software, and the anorexic “support” available on your web site offer
    > next-to-nothing by way of relevant assistance, I made the mistake of
    > continuing to address this problem myself (since it’s also the weekend and
    > tech support throughout the galaxy is closed).
    >
    > Am now left with a Mac (os 10.2.6) that is missing fonts as part of its basic
    > desktop display, which means that my desktop folders are all nameless and
    > indistinguishable, my email program has blank stretches of screen where there
    > used to be informative text, and the Font Reserve Browser is quitting after
    > the following error window pops up upon launching, and I click ok (a copy of
    > the error window is attached herewith).
    >
    > So far, Font Reserve has left me sadder than Bush’s stealing of the last
    > election, multiplied by the recent wealth redistribution package, anna nicole
    > smith, jeans with faux fading on the ass and thighs and without pockets,
    > starbucks, and the insidiousness of planned obsolescence with the computer
    > industry.
    >
    > I need help getting my computer running right away, with all the proper fonts
    > where they should be, and your product doing what it’s supposed to do.
    >
    > Thank you for your assistance. You have my sympathies for being unfairly
    > compensated for the stressful time you put in at the grindstone, whilst your
    > senior executives wipe their asses with 24K gold leaf.
    >
    > Glad tidings.
    >
    > – Roy G. Biv

  • http://www.extensis.com spike

    Learn to love Suitcase. It is the best of a bad lot. Font Book is clearly only for the casual user not the power user. Its probably fine for those that need to activate A font, not the entire Adobe collection.

    Unfortunately Apple doesn’t really make that clear do they?

  • http://blab-o-rama.com beerzie boy, windows (l)user

    i’m sorry, i’ve been out of town for a couple of weeks. am i to understand that bill gates took over apple?

  • http://www.digitalcatharsis.com the mighty jimbo

    boy am i glad i’m not a power user. i just use my Ti to surf for porn and leave witty comments on weblogs.

  • http://www.rubbo.com grand master fat

    Oh, don’t get me started on Font Book. I had the exact experience as you, unfortunately the only backup I had of my fonts included about 8 million handwriting-esque fonts that nobody can explain why we bought them. So now I have to go clean all of those out. Now I only have 80 fonts or so in Font Book lest I crash again, and the auto activation, or even the abiity to activate a font while in a program does not work.

    Well two steps forward, two steps back.

  • Jeb Stuart

    Suitcase. There are no options.

  • Jack Greenwood

    Fonts in 70+ locations? Ahh, the love of a unixy/linuxy system. Reading this entry made me feel oh so much like it was 1993 not 2003. So Apple made font rendering just sublime in OSX but they forgot the management stuff. Good God. Hate to say it but this is classic Apple leaving behind what it once thought to be important: publishing. I mean really, Suitcase came about in the days of System 6 for not just fonts but DAs. I can believe one still has to use it for something so “core” to the OS. What’ll they think of next? three letter extensions to indicate the content of a file?!

  • http://www.fidragolf.com geoffrey

    same experience. You have given me hope that it is resolvable. I will never open fontbook again. EVER. I don’t care if I’m on a G8 in 2015, it will never happen. The horror. But hey, better than worm viruses.

    The thing that really bugs me… nothing from apple. Not a damn peep. With everybody screaming and freaking out. Not a single fricking word on how to resolve this…

    FIX IT APPLE.

    NOW.

    No more iPod updates. No more iTunes. Screw Safari. And take your damn iSync and shove it. I NEED FONTS. WORDS. LETTERS. SERIF AND SANS. The next unit past 1′s and 0′s. If you can’t do that, don’t do anything. At least my friends with PC’s have letters on their screens.

    Font book… Font vortex more like. d@#$heads…

  • Rich

    Font Book fu*ked me too. Suitcase is incompatiable with Panther at least for another few weeks, Font Book is unusable for more than 50 fonts. I am a designer with deadlines and now I can’t work. Thanks Apple, I love using Verdana on all my projects.

  • http://www.blurbomat.com dj blurb

    Rich,

    Suitcase X11 might be problematic, but I’m running Suitcase 10.1.3 just fine on Panther.

  • http://www.dreier.com dreier

    I found the solution. My Rapidograph. If you don’t know what it is then you’re too young to appreciate what Apple did for our industry. I’m about to toss my OSX and get back to 9 where I can run a non-corel-like version of Illustrator and actually use fonts with ATM. I now have Font Reserve, Suitcase and lots of AOL disks to line my trash can.

  • http://none poaast

    It seems that no one has mentioned has confused Font Book gets (by confesed I mean CRASHES) whenever you try to load a PostScript font. But It does love TrueType, and now I can use all the crappy unkearned fonts out there. I’m put suitcase X1 back….now I just have to find my fonts.

  • Emily

    Christ! I’ve upgraded to Panther, and I don’t *think* I’m using Font Book, but I suspect that somewhere, secretly, it is oozing into the shard remnants of Suitcase that remain. And last year, I thought Apple couldn’t make the font issue ANY worse. And these Open Face fonts: are we supposed to repurchase all of our fonts to get them to get along with Indesign? Ahh, helvetica.

  • http://rebecky.com rebecca

    If only I had found this blog entry sixteen hours ago! FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK!

    * smooths hair, adjusts glasses *

  • http://www.douglashouston.com Doug

    The much anticipated Font Book…. I too wish I had found this site some 10 hours ago before I attempted to install ALL the Adobe Font Folio fonts into the system! I noticed the problem when I tried to go on the web and the text was nothing but numbers and fractions, same sort of thing in email. I hate you apple….at least for bit.

  • http://netherlogic.com/gullet tim

    I wish I had found this earlier, too. ATM was my ideal font manager. Why don’t we have it for OS X? Who do I have to “service” at Adobe to make this happen?!

    Harrumph.

  • Tim Taylor

    THANK GOD FOR YOU GUYS! I was just given the task of installing Panther on all our design macs over the Christmas break. I was just trying to figure out this Font book thing and how to install our font collection – an average one for our biz of about a thousand fonts. We are getting Suitcase sent down to us (we are in Bermuda) so I guess I should wait for that huh?

  • http://www.blurbomat.com dj blurb

    DO NOT TOUCH FONT BOOK. Wait for Suitcase. Also, pour yourself a drink or two whilte waiting for Suitcase.

  • Barney

    FONT BOOK FURY *%£@)(
    Have just installed Panther – was trying to make the final passover to OSX – now one and a half days later I am back working in OS9.2.2 – hale-flipping-lujah!!

    I like others had only wished I had found this site earlier – it seems there will constantly be a problem with the most up-to-date releases from Apple that will never work until all other vendors catch up – so a word from the wounded – if it ain’t broke . . don’t upgrade until the fix is available :( :( :(

  • http://www.stefanculotta.com/ jiminy crooked

    ok, get this…i’m reading the help file in X1, and it says that fonts may not preview unless activated in font book. that means i have to add all of my fonts to font book, activate all 1,500 of them, THEN open suitcase and activate, then deactivate them all, and THEN I should be able to see my font faces in the preview pane?

    I don’t get it. the whole setup was working fine when I first installed X1 on Panther…then, some damaged font caused a crash, and ultimately forced me to reinstall suitcase. since then, my preview pane says “review not available” for every font. i dod what the help section said for a few fonts…you know to test it out…and it worked. but for about 50 fonts, it took about a half hour. so, to see the other 1450 or so fonts in suitcase, i need, what, about another fifteen hours to deal with this issue before i can do any real work.

    lovely.

    not to mention, font book puts all of it’s known fonts into your library/fonts/ file so the entire system is slowed to a crawl on this 533 G4.

    way to go, stevie boy…why don’t you go make another cartoon for the kids?!?!

  • jiminy crooked

    alright…got it. i took all the fonts out of that library/fonts folder [note:that's the user/library, not the system/library!] and trashed my fontbook prefs and suitcase prefs, reloaded all fonts into X1, and now i’m back where I was before i encountered that corrupted font.

    i’ve been using OSX for about two months now, and all i can say is “it sure is pretty!”

    I knew i should have waited for X.5…maybe they’ll have it finished by then?

  • hez

    Thank god – I thought I was an experienced mac user, a techie of sorts, and now I had completely lost it with Font Book in Panther. You have know idea how relieved I was to find and read your article and all the info below. No doubt there will be an update shortly and not have to wait until the release of Mac OSX1 Godzilla!?

  • http://www.hofro.com Bruce

    Ditto on all of the above with an added Font Book quirk. If you disable “certain” fonts (nobody can tell me which ones) you’ll disable Safari, the Preferences folder, help and who knows what else?
    As far as I’m concerned, the people at Apple have whipped up a batch of Jim Jones Kool Aid, named it Panther, and will be watching dumbfounded as we, the Mac faithful, fall to the groundónever to buy another upgrade, or CPU from them again.
    What an absolute shame.

  • http://www.maclife.de Leo

    Oh dear…

    I¥ve been using all of these mentioned programs under classic Mac OS and Mac OS X (now 10.3). The biggest disaster ever wasn¥t caused by Fontreserve, Suitcase or Fontbook, it was caused by Font Doctor. Before I had about 300.000 fonts ready to use, after touching them with Font Doctor only 15.000 were left. Just some days ago versiontracker showed the update of Font Doctor, mentioning some kind of troubles in former versions…

    It seems to me that fonts are still some kind of unloved child to Apple.